Brave Employee Declines ‘Promotion’ That Would Slash His Pay or Skyrocket His Hours

When an employee gets offered a promotion, it’s not so farfetched to think it comes with a salary increase. However, one employee’s experience of being offered a promotion came with a twist.

A Promotion with a Twist

man aiming to shake hands ss2189107219
Image Credit: Kateryna Onyshchuk/Shutterstock.

The employee, who works as a vendor in the grocery industry, was called into the boss’s office and presented with a promotion offer.

The peculiar aspect of this offer was that it would either lead to a 20% reduction in the employee’s annual income or necessitate working an additional 10 hours per week to maintain the current income level.

As a sales position, the vendor role operates on a commission basis, allowing the employee to be highly efficient and maximize earnings for minimum hours.

The employee had consistently demonstrated high sales growth and numbers, outperforming other sales representatives in the local market.

Evaluating the Trade-Offs

coworkers shake hands ss1963272106
Illustration. Photo Credit: fizkes/Shutterstock.

The promotion involved transitioning to a supervisor role, which is compensated hourly. The employee calculated their average hourly income in the current role and found it to be 20% higher than the hourly rate being offered for the supervisor position.

Upon discussing this discrepancy with the boss, it became evident that the employer was aware of the difference in compensation.

The boss emphasized the potential for moving into higher-paying supervisor positions in the future but stressed that accepting the current offer was a necessary step in climbing the corporate ladder.

Turning Down the Offer

man saying no ss1174630021
Image Credit: Cast Of Thousands/Shutterstock.

After evaluating the trade-offs and implications of the offer, the employee decided to turn it down. The prospect of taking on more responsibilities and working additional hours without corresponding financial benefits did not align with the employee’s values and expectations.

Shared Experiences

talking businessmen dp37386285
Photo Credit. gstockstudio/Deposit Photos.

The story has resonated with several people who shared similar experiences and challenges. One commenter recounted an instance where a promotion led to being just over the threshold for overtime eligibility, resulting in a decrease in overall compensation.

“I had two such ‘promotions’. The one I totally didn’t expect was going from a grade 1 engineer to grade 2. It included a raise. 1 month into my new position, the overtime policy changed & all engineers who were grade 2 & above were no longer eligible for overtime. I checked the law & with my new salary, I was $20 per year over the threshold for ‘exempt’.”

The Suspicion Surrounding Future Promises

thinking man ss1450014455
Photo Credit: Damir Khabirov/Shutterstock.

Someone who expressed skepticism about promises of better positions in the future offered a different perspective. They pointed out the uncertainty and potential risk of being stuck in a less favorable position for an extended period, emphasizing the importance of evaluating the reliability of future prospects.

Insights from the Grocery Industry

grocery workers dp164966136
Image Credit: ArturVerkhovetskiy/Deposit Photos.

A user with experience in the grocery industry shared insights into vendors’ earnings, citing an example of a vendor who earned more than their manager due to commission caps.

“I was a grocery manager for years. The one who stocked my store made much more than his manager because the stores he worked were max capping his commissions. He chose to work as early as possible (often starting at 4 a.m.) and ending his day early afternoon. He made more than I did yearly due to his sales. If he ever took a new position higher up he’d have taken a massive pay cut.”

The Importance of Understanding Offers

man and woman shaking hands ss776540299
Image Credit: djrandco/Shutterstock.

Several people commended the employee for understanding the offer’s implications and making an informed decision.

One pointed out that the employer might have hoped the employee did not fully grasp the offer, highlighting the importance of awareness and critical evaluation of career opportunities.

Equitable Development & Career Advancement

man and woman shaking hands ss1253245204
Image Credit: fizkes/Shutterstock.

In light of the employee’s experience, equitable development ³ in the workplace becomes a focal point. Organizations need to implement strategies that ensure all employees, regardless of their role, have the opportunity to advance and achieve their full potential.

Addressing disparities and fostering an inclusive environment can prevent promotions with unfavorable conditions.

Advocating for Equity In Career Opportunities

hiring job dp10369506
Image Credit: zimmytws/DepositPhotos.

Promoting equity in career advancement opportunities is essential. Employees should be vigilant and advocate for equitable treatment, ensuring that career progression does not come at the expense of fair compensation.

Organizations are responsible for providing transparent and fair advancement opportunities to foster trust and engagement among employees.

Inclusive Support for Career Decisions

job contract ss1016730169
Image Credit: Andre Boukreev/Shutterstock.

The employee’s decision to turn down the promotion highlights the need for inclusive career support. Organizations should strive to offer equitable career support, ensuring that employees are well informed and can make decisions that align with their professional goals and values.

This includes clarifying the implications of career moves and guaranteeing transparency in compensation practices.

More from Viral Chatter

man woman phone ss2159274773
Image Credit: Pheelings media/Shutterstock.

In recent times, the dynamics of job hunting have evolved, with many turning to online platforms to find their next opportunity.

One such platform that has been a go-to for many is Indeed.

However, recent user experiences suggest that the platform might not be as effective as it once was.

“I’m just not built for a 9-5 no matter what it is”- Woman Ready to Quit New Job After Just 4 Days

woman working hard dp62765133
Image Credit: olly18/Deposit Photos.

A recent viral post highlighted a sentiment that many can relate to: the challenges and dissatisfaction of traditional 9-5 jobs.

A woman expressed her desire to leave her new position only four days after starting, sparking a wave of empathy and shared experiences from others.

Sources

sources 1 2
Image Credit: Krakenimages.com/DepositPhotos.
  1. reddit.com/r/antiwork/comments/162lz46/offered_a_promotion_and_to_my_surprise_a_pay_cut/
  2. cultureplusconsulting.com/2019/11/10/equitable-development-optimise-talent/
  3. recruitee.com/articles/equity-in-workplace
  4. pulsely.io/dei-initiatives/provide-inclusive-career-support

This article was produced and syndicated by Viral Chatter.

Martha A. Lavallie
Martha A. Lavallie
Author & Editor | + posts

Martha is a journalist with close to a decade of experience in uncovering and reporting on the most compelling stories of our time. Passionate about staying ahead of the curve, she specializes in shedding light on trending topics and captivating global narratives. Her insightful articles have garnered acclaim, making her a trusted voice in today's dynamic media landscape.