Debt vs. Prosperity: 7 States Face Taxes, 7 Stay Strong

As federal aid dwindles and economic pressures mount, states across the U.S. face diverging fiscal futures. While some grapple with crushing debt and looming tax hikes, others flourish with robust economies and enviable financial freedom. 

The Debt Dilemma: Understanding the Crisis

State debt accumulates through a complex web of factors, including pension obligations, infrastructure investments, and economic downturns.

Remember that flood of federal pandemic aid? It was like a financial life raft for many states, masking underlying issues that are now bubbling to the surface.

As this temporary relief fades away, some states are finding themselves in hot water.

One key indicator economists use to gauge fiscal health is the debt-to-GDP ratio. The higher this ratio, the more likely a state is to face financial troubles down the road.

Top 7 States Drowning in Debt

While many states are grappling with financial difficulties, some are facing more significant hurdles than others. Let’s take a closer look at seven states that are navigating particularly choppy fiscal waters:

1. Connecticut: The Nutmeg State tops the chart for debt burden. Connecticut’s net tax-supported debt as a percentage of its revenue was a staggering 103.8% in fiscal year 2022, the highest in the nation. (ref)
2. Illinois: The Land of Lincoln is facing what some call “the worst pension crisis in the nation.” (ref) Despite recent improvements in cash flow due to federal aid, Illinois continues to struggle with long-term financial stability and unfunded pension liabilities.
3. New Jersey: New Jersey has historically been among the states with high debt levels. The state has made efforts to reduce its debt, with overall state debt down nearly $40 billion since 2018.
4. California: The Golden State is facing a severe budget deficit. According to the Legislative Analyst’s Office, California faces a budget problem of $68 billion in the upcoming budget process, largely due to a severe revenue decline in 2022-23.
5. New York: New York is among the states contending with deficits. Governor Kathy Hochul is facing pressure from progressive lawmakers pushing for new or higher taxes on the wealthy and corporations, even as she has vowed not to raise income taxes this session.
6. Alaska: The state is dealing with a nearly $1 billion deficit. Governor Mike Dunleavy has proposed using savings to cover this shortfall, highlighting the fiscal challenges Alaska is facing.
7. Minnesota: While not currently in deficit, budget forecasters have warned that the state is on track to face a shortfall beginning in 2026, (ref) indicating potential future fiscal challenges.

As they navigate these challenges, residents may face potential tax increases, reductions in public services, or both in the coming years.

The Ripple Effect: How State Debt Impacts Daily Life

First off, public services could take a hit. That pothole on your street that’s been begging for attention? It might have to wait a bit longer. 

Then there’s the dreaded T-word: taxes. When states are drowning in debt, they often turn to tax increases to stay afloat. This could mean higher income taxes, property taxes, or even new fees for services you use every day.

Businesses might think twice about setting up shop in a state with shaky finances, potentially leading to fewer job opportunities and slower economic growth.

The Fiscally Fit Seven: States with Enviable Financial Health

Let’s shift gears and look at the states that are riding high on the waves of fiscal freedom. These seven are showing the rest of the country how it’s done:

1. New Hampshire: Boasting top rankings in overall freedom and fiscal policy, New Hampshire keeps its tax burden low and its government efficient. It’s like a masterclass in fiscal management.
2. Florida: With a top-notch fiscal policy ranking, Florida is seeing both economic growth and a population boom. It ranks 8th overall in freedom and 4th in fiscal policy. (ref)
3. Tennessee: The Volunteer State is stepping up in the fiscal freedom game. With strong fiscal health and a tax policy that’s music to residents’ ears, Tennessee ranks 6th overall and 2nd in fiscal policy.
4. Alaska: Alaska ranks 2nd overall in freedom and 11th in fiscal policy, proving that its financial management is as robust as its natural beauty.
5. Utah: The Beehive State is buzzing with fiscal responsibility. Utah ranks 4th in the nation for fiscal health according to the Truth in Accounting report, with a Taxpayer Surplus of $12,100.
6. Wyoming: This state isn’t just about wide-open spaces – it’s also about wide-open opportunities for fiscal health. Wyoming ranks 3rd in regulatory policy and 14th overall in freedom.
7. North Dakota: North Dakota earned an “A” grade from Truth in Accounting for 2023, indicating strong financial health.

These states are proving that with careful management, low debt, and responsible tax policies, it’s possible to maintain fiscal health while providing for residents’ needs.

The Secret Sauce: What Sets Fiscally Free States Apart

These fiscally free states have a few tricks up their sleeves.

First, they tend to keep a tight rein on spending. It’s like following a strict budget at home – these states prioritize essential services while avoiding unnecessary splurges.

Second, they create business-friendly environments. Low taxes and sensible regulations attract companies, which in turn create jobs and boost the economy. It’s a virtuous cycle that keeps the fiscal wheels turning smoothly.

The Urban Factor: How City Finances Impact State Debt

The health of a state’s major cities can have a big impact on its overall financial picture. It’s like having a leaky faucet in your house – if you don’t fix it, it can lead to bigger problems down the line.

Many cities are facing declining commercial property values, especially as work-from-home trends continue. This means less tax revenue for city coffers, which can ripple out to affect state finances.

Some cities are getting creative with urban fiscal management. They’re exploring public-private partnerships, rethinking zoning laws, and finding new ways to attract businesses and residents. 

Navigating the Fiscal Divide

So, what’s next for states on both sides of the fiscal divide? 

For those drowning in debt, it’s time to grab a life preserver and start swimming. This might mean tough choices like restructuring pension systems, finding new revenue sources, or making strategic cuts to spending.

On the flip side, fiscally free states can’t rest on their laurels. They need to stay vigilant, continually adapting to changing economic conditions and demographic shifts.

What the Future Holds

As we look to the future, the stark contrast between states drowning in debt and those enjoying fiscal freedom highlights the critical importance of sound financial management and forward-thinking policies.

After all, when it comes to state finances, we’re all in the same boat.

Read Next

Retirement isn’t the time to let taxes eat into your hard-earned savings.

• Keep Every Penny: 9 States With No Retirement Income Tax