Hooked on Fish? Think Twice Before Dining on These Ocean Dwellers

When the bounty of the sea is just a menu selection away, it’s easy to forget that not all fish are created equal—especially when it comes to our health and the environment. While fish is celebrated for its nutritional benefits, certain species come with a hefty side of concerns.

From mercury levels to environmental impact, let’s dive into the fishy details about which fish might be better left off your plate.

1. King Mackerel

king mackerel ss2195287987
Image Credit: NiAk Stock/Shutterstock

King Mackerel is a fish that’s as regal as its name suggests, but its high mercury content might make you think twice about consuming it regularly. This species is known to inhabit warmer waters and can live a long life, which contributes to the accumulation of significant amounts of mercury in its system over the years.

Regular consumption of high-mercury fish like King Mackerel can lead to mercury poisoning (ref), which is particularly dangerous for pregnant women and children.

Moreover, the fishing methods used to catch King Mackerel often raise environmental concerns. These include long-lining and gillnetting, which can result in high bycatch rates of non-target species, disrupting marine ecosystems.

The depletion of King Mackerel in certain areas also highlights the need for more sustainable fishing practices to ensure the species’ survival and the health of our oceans.

2. Orange Roughy

orange roughy ss2101530691
Image Credit: Brendan Lin/Shutterstock

Ah, Orange Roughy, the poster child for overfishing woes. This deep-sea dweller has a life span that can exceed 100 years but matures slowly, making it highly vulnerable to overfishing.

The population of Orange Roughy has plummeted in various parts of the world due to intensive fishing practices (ref), and recovery remains a slow process due to its reproductive habits.

Eating Orange Roughy also poses health risks because of its high levels of mercury. The longevity of the fish allows it to accumulate more toxins over its lifetime compared to faster-growing species. Therefore, frequent consumption of Orange Roughy can contribute to elevated mercury levels in humans, posing a particular risk to developmental and neurological health.

3. Atlantic Bluefin Tuna

atlantic bluefin tuna ss76758124
Image Credit: lunamarina/Shutterstock

Atlantic Bluefin Tuna is a sought-after delicacy, especially in high-end sushi markets, but its popularity comes at a high cost. This species is critically endangered and suffering from severe overfishing to meet global demand.

The scarcity of this majestic fish is a dire warning about the impacts of unsustainable seafood consumption and the international trade in luxury fish products.

Health-wise, the Atlantic Bluefin Tuna packs a punch in terms of mercury content. Due to its large size and high position in the food chain, it accumulates more mercury than many other fish species.

Regularly eating high-mercury fish like Bluefin Tuna can lead to significant health issues, especially affecting the immune system and cardiovascular health (ref).

4. Tilefish

tilefish ss230929078
Image Credit: feathercollector/Shutterstock

Tilefish might not be as well-known as some other species on this list, but it’s just as worthy of caution. Found in the Gulf of Mexico and Atlantic Ocean, Tilefish are subject to mercury contamination.

Similar to other long-living fish, their lengthy lifespan allows them to accumulate toxins from their diet, which primarily consists of smaller fish.

Environmental concerns also shadow the harvesting of Tilefish. The methods used, such as bottom trawling, are destructive to the seafloor and can lead to considerable bycatch. These practices not only harm local ecosystems but also reduce biodiversity, which is crucial for maintaining healthy ocean environments.

5. Shark

tigershark ss2263403737
Image Credit: Jsegalexplore/Shutterstock.

Last but certainly not least, sharks are as dangerous on your plate as they are impressive in the ocean. Being top predators, sharks accumulate high levels of mercury in their bodies, making them a risky choice for regular consumption.

The health risks associated with mercury-laden fish include neurological damage and compromised kidney function.

From an environmental perspective, the decline in shark populations due to overfishing is alarming. Many species are now threatened or endangered. The loss of these apex predators can lead to imbalances in marine ecosystems, illustrating the far-reaching impacts of human dietary choices on ocean health.

6. Swordfish

swordfish ss2046528392
Image Credit: Wirestock Creators/Shutterstock

Swordfish, a popular catch in many upscale restaurants due to its firm texture and rich flavor, carries significant mercury risks. As one of the larger predatory fish, Swordfish accumulate toxins more readily through their diet. This can lead to high levels of mercury, which are particularly harmful during pregnancy and can affect neurological development in fetuses and children.

Environmentally, the method of catching Swordfish often involves longline fishing, which can inadvertently catch and kill other marine life, including sea turtles and seabirds. This method has led to numerous ecological concerns, particularly regarding the bycatch of species that are already at risk.

7. Chilean Sea Bass

chilean sea bass ss1893050143
Image Credit: theLIMEs/Shutterstock

Also known as Patagonian Toothfish, Chilean Sea Bass has become a culinary favorite, but at a cost. It’s often victim to illegal, unreported, and unregulated fishing due to its high market value. This has led to significant sustainability concerns, with some stocks under threat of collapse.

Bottom trawling fishing techniques often damage the deep-water habitats of Chilean Sea Bass. Moreover, like many deep-sea fish, it has a long lifespan, which leads to high levels of contaminants such as mercury, making regular consumption a health concern.

8. European Eel

european eel ss1135285847
Image Credit: Picture Partners/Shutterstock

European Eel is another species to be wary of, primarily due to severe overfishing and its listing as critically endangered. Eels are often caught young in the wild and then farmed, a practice that further threatens wild populations and disrupts local ecosystems.

Aside from the environmental issues, eels are high in PCBs and dioxins—chemicals that have been linked to cancer and other serious health problems (ref). These factors make the European Eel a less desirable choice for both your plate and the planet.

9. Imported Shrimp

shrimps ss451015831
Image Credit: DenisProduction.com/Shutterstock

Imported Shrimp makes up a significant portion of shrimp consumed in many countries, but its production is riddled with problems. Farming practices, especially in parts of Asia, often involve poor management and harmful chemicals, which can lead to contaminated shrimp.

Furthermore, the destruction of mangrove forests for shrimp farming has severe ecological impacts, including loss of habitat for many marine and terrestrial wildlife species.

The labor practices in the shrimp industry also raise ethical concerns, with many reports highlighting exploitative conditions and even forced labor. Thus, opting for locally sourced or sustainably certified shrimp is generally a better choice.

10. Grouper

grouper ss2259606117
Image Credit: Daryl Duda/Shutterstock

Grouper, a favorite among fish lovers for its moist, mild-flavored meat, often comes from sources where overfishing is a significant issue. Groupers are particularly vulnerable because they are slow to mature and reproduce, making them susceptible to overexploitation.

Additionally, Groupers are often caught using methods that damage coral reefs and other vital underwater habitats. High levels of mercury are also a concern in larger specimens, making them another fish to consider avoiding or limiting in your diet.

As the demand for seafood continues to grow, it’s important to stay informed about the origins and impacts of the fish we consume. By choosing seafood from sustainable sources and avoiding species that are overfished or high in contaminants, we can help protect our health and ensure the health of our oceans for future generations.

Martha A. Lavallie
Martha A. Lavallie
Author & Editor | + posts

Martha is a journalist with close to a decade of experience in uncovering and reporting on the most compelling stories of our time. Passionate about staying ahead of the curve, she specializes in shedding light on trending topics and captivating global narratives. Her insightful articles have garnered acclaim, making her a trusted voice in today's dynamic media landscape.