Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History

Every Sunday, millions of fans watch quarterbacks transform from athletes into modern-day gladiators. But who truly stands above the rest? 

We reveal the most electrifying, record-shattering signal-callers in NFL history—warriors who didn’t just play the game, but fundamentally changed how it’s understood. 

1. Tom Brady

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » tom brady ss2452791225 adyh
Image Credit: OSCAR GONZALEZ FUENTES/Shutterstock

Team/s: New England Patriots, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Passing yards: 89,214
Years active: 2000-2023

The undisputed GOAT of quarterback history, Brady’s career is nothing short of legendary. He won an unprecedented seven Super Bowl titles and was named Super Bowl MVP five times.

What sets Brady apart isn’t just his raw statistics, but his unparalleled ability to perform under pressure. (ref) He became the first quarterback to defeat all 32 NFL teams and holds the record for most Pro Bowl selections at 15.

2. Drew Brees

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » drew brees ss142432357 adyh
Image Credit: Debby Wong/Shutterstock

Team/s: San Diego Chargers, New Orleans Saints
Passing yards: 80,358
Years active: 2001-2020

Brees revolutionized the passing game with his incredible accuracy and consistency. His precision was so remarkable that he became a benchmark for quarterbacks looking to master the art of passing.

3. Peyton Manning

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » peyton manning ss4138714 adyh
Image Credit: Brad Sauter/Shutterstock

Team/s: Indianapolis Colts, Denver Broncos
Passing yards: 71,940
Years active: 1998-2015

A true mastermind of the quarterback position, Manning was selected to 14 Pro Bowls and won two Super Bowl championships. His football intelligence was legendary, earning him five MVP awards and transforming the way quarterbacks approach the game.

4. Brett Favre

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » brett favre ss57233914 adyh
Image Credit: Leon Brezer/Shutterstock

Team/s: Atlanta Falcons, Green Bay Packers, New York Jets, Minnesota Vikings
Passing yards: 71,838
Years active: 1991-2010

Known for his incredible durability and gunslinger mentality, Favre became the first player in NFL history to have nine seasons with 30+ touchdown passes. His consecutive starts streak is the stuff of NFL folklore.

5. Ben Roethlisberger

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » ben roethlisberger ss104430416 adyh
Image Credit: s_bukley/Shutterstock

Team/s: Pittsburgh Steelers
Passing yards: 64,088
Years active: 2004-2021

“Big Ben” was renowned for his ability to play outside the traditional passing pocket. He won two Super Bowls and became the youngest quarterback to win a Super Bowl at age 23.

6. Philip Rivers

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » philip rivers ss1824770261 adyh
Image Credit: April Visuals/Shutterstock

Team/s: San Diego/Los Angeles Chargers, Indianapolis Colts
Passing yards: 63,440
Years active: 2004-2020

Rivers was a model of consistency, known for his unique throwing motion and competitive spirit. His ability to read defenses made him a formidable quarterback throughout his career.

7. Matt Ryan

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » matt ryan ss1481109356 adyh
Image Credit: Jamie Lamor Thompson/Shutterstock

Team/s: Atlanta Falcons, Indianapolis Colts
Passing yards: 62,792
Years active: 2008-2022

Nicknamed “Matty Ice” for his cool performance under pressure, Ryan was named NFL MVP in 2016 and led the Falcons to a memorable Super Bowl appearance.

8. Dan Marino

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » dan marino ss78859948 adyh
Image Credit: Debby Wong/Shutterstock

Team/s: Miami Dolphins
Passing yards: 61,361
Years active: 1983-1999

Many football experts consider Marino the greatest quarterback in NFL history before Brady. His quick release and ability to read defenses were revolutionary for his time.

9. Aaron Rodgers

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » aaron rodgers ss83582323 adyh
Image Credit: MPH Photos/Shutterstock

Team/s: Green Bay Packers, New York Jets
Passing yards: 59,055
Years active: 2005-2023

The only quarterback in NFL history with over 400 passing touchdowns (ref) and a career passer rating over 100, Rodgers is known for his incredible arm talent and precision.

10. Matthew Stafford

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » matthew stafford ss107405354 adyh
Image Credit: Kathy Hutchins/Shutterstock

Team/s: Detroit Lions, Los Angeles Rams
Passing yards: 58,016
Years active: 2009-present

Stafford’s cannon-like arm and veteran presence helped lead the Rams to a Super Bowl victory, showcasing his elite quarterback skills.

11. Eli Manning

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » eli manning ss1627200412 adyh
Image Credit: Debby Wong/Shutterstock

Team/s: New York Giants
Passing yards: 57,023
Years active: 2004-2019

Defying the odds, Manning etched his name in NFL history by leading the Giants to two miraculous Super Bowl victories against the seemingly unbeatable New England Patriots. His underdog performances, particularly in Super Bowl XLII where he defeated the first team to win all 16 regular-season games, solidified his reputation as a clutch quarterback who thrived under immense pressure.

12. John Elway

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » john elway wc
Image Credit: Tech. Sgt. Marc Barnes, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Team/s: Denver Broncos
Passing yards: 51,475
Years active: 1983-1998

Elway’s extraordinary mobility and cannon-like arm transformed the quarterback position, making him a nightmare for defensive coordinators. Capping off his illustrious career, he secured back-to-back Super Bowl championships, riding into retirement as a true NFL legend.

13. Warren Moon

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » warren moon ss1446634763 adyh
Image Credit: Eugene Powers/Shutterstock

Team/s: Houston Oilers, Minnesota Vikings, Seattle Seahawks, Kansas City Chiefs
Passing yards: 49,325
Years active: 1978-2000

Moon blazed a trail for African American quarterbacks by first dominating the Canadian Football League before breaking barriers in the NFL. His unprecedented success culminated in becoming the first African-American quarterback inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

14. Dan Fouts

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » dan fouts wc
Image Credit: Rex Lilly, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Team/s: San Diego Chargers
Passing yards: 43,040
Years active: 1973-1987

Fouts revolutionized offensive football through the innovative “Air Coryell” system, (ref) turning the San Diego Chargers into an aerial assault powerhouse. His consecutive seasons leading the league in passing yards demonstrated a level of consistency that redefined quarterback expectations in the 1970s and early 1980s.

15. Kerry Collins

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » kerry collins wc
Image Credit: Ray Montgomery. Cropped by User:Blueag9., CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Team/s: Carolina Panthers, New Orleans Saints, New York Giants, Oakland Raiders, Tennessee Titans, Indianapolis Colts
Passing yards: 40,922
Years active: 1995-2011

A Penn State legend, Collins transitioned from college football stardom to a journeyman NFL career that spanned six different teams. His most notable achievement came in 2000, when he led the New York Giants to the NFC championship and a Super Bowl XXXV appearance.

16. Joe Montana

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » joe montana ss1068922754 adyh
Image Credit: meunierd/Shutterstock

Team/s: San Francisco 49ers, Kansas City Chiefs
Passing yards: 40,55
Years active: 1979-1994

Nicknamed “Joe Cool” for his calm demeanor under pressure, Montana is widely considered the most clutch quarterback in NFL history. He won four Super Bowls and was named Super Bowl MVP three times, setting the standard for quarterback excellence .

17. Johnny Unitas

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » johnny unitas wc
Image Credit: Here, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Team/s: Baltimore Colts, San Diego Chargers
Passing yards: 40,239
Years active: 1956-1973

Unitas is often credited with transforming the quarterback position from a supporting role to a leadership role. He was the first quarterback to throw for over 40,000 yards (ref) and was named NFL MVP three times during his legendary career .

18. Kirk Cousins

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » kirk cousins ss1628151094 adyh
Image Credit: Steve Jacobson/Shutterstock

Team/s: Washington Commanders, Minnesota Vikings
Passing yards: 39,471
Years active: 2012-2023

Cousins has been a model of consistency, throwing for over 4,000 yards in multiple seasons. He signed one of the most lucrative guaranteed contracts in NFL history with the Minnesota Vikings, showcasing his value as a reliable starting quarterback .

19. Derek Carr

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » derek carr ss1519319426 adyh
Image Credit: Jamie Lamor Thompson/Shutterstock

Team/s: Oakland/Las Vegas Raiders, New Orleans Saints
Passing yards: 39,100
Years active: 2014-2023

Carr became the heartbeat of the Raiders’ offense, bringing stability and leadership during a transformative period for the franchise. His three Pro Bowl selections highlighted his ability to perform at an elite level despite constant team transitions.

20. Andy Dalton

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » andy dalton wc
Image Credit: Navin75, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Team/s: Cincinnati Bengals, Dallas Cowboys, Chicago Bears, New Orleans Saints
Passing yards: 38,511
Years active: 2011-2023

Nicknamed the “Red Rocket” for his fiery red hair and quick playing style, Dalton became the face of the Cincinnati Bengals’ offense. His multiple playoff appearances demonstrated a consistency that made him a cornerstone quarterback throughout his career.

21. Boomer Esiason

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » boomer esiason ss2532290509 adyh
Image Credit: Dylanhatfield/Shutterstock

Team/s: Cincinnati Bengals, New York Jets, Arizona Cardinals
Passing yards: 37,920
Years active: 1984-1997

Esiason was known for his powerful arm and leadership on the field, leading the Cincinnati Bengals to a Super Bowl appearance in 1988. Beyond football, he became a prominent broadcaster and charitable advocate, particularly for cystic fibrosis research .

22. Donovan McNabb

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » donovan mcnabb ss54087499 adyh
Image Credit: Grindstone Media Group/Shutterstock

Team/s: Philadelphia Eagles, Washington Commanders, Minnesota Vikings
Passing yards: 37,276
Years active: 1999-2011

McNabb was a dynamic quarterback who revolutionized the Eagles’ offense with his dual-threat capabilities. He led the Eagles to five NFC Championship games and one Super Bowl appearance, becoming one of the most successful quarterbacks in franchise history .

23. Matt Hasselbeck

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » matt hasselback wc
Image Credit: Mike Morbeck, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Team/s: Green Bay Packers, Seattle Seahawks, Tennessee Titans, Indianapolis Colts
Passing yards: 36,638
Years active: 1999-2015

Hasselbeck emerged as a key leader for the Seattle Seahawks, guiding the team through its most successful period in franchise history. He was known for his intelligence on the field and became a fan favorite for his competitive spirit and leadership .

24. Alex Smith

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » alex smith ss1740374 adyh
Image Credit: Glenn W. Walker/Shutterstock

Team/s: San Francisco 49ers, Kansas City Chiefs, Washington Commanders
Passing yards: 35,650
Years active: 2005-2020

Smith’s career was defined by remarkable resilience, overcoming multiple coaching changes and a near-career-ending leg injury. His comeback story became an inspiration to athletes everywhere, showcasing incredible determination and medical recovery .

25. Jim Kelly

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » jim kelly wc
Image Credit: Sgt. Gaelen LowersSmall RSS Icon, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Team/s: Buffalo Bills
Passing yards: 35,467
Years active: 1986-1996

Kelly was the heart of the Buffalo Bills’ legendary no-huddle offense, leading the team to four consecutive Super Bowl appearances. Despite never winning a championship, he is considered one of the most important quarterbacks in Bills history .

26. Jay Cutler

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » jay cutler wc
Image Credit: Onetwo1 at English Wikipedia, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Team/s: Denver Broncos, Chicago Bears, Miami Dolphins
Passing yards: 35,133
Years active: 2006-2017

Cutler was known for his strong arm and nonchalant playing style, becoming a polarizing figure in Chicago Bears history. His career was marked by potential and inconsistency, making him one of the most interesting quarterbacks of his generation .

27. Ryan Fitzpatrick

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » ryan fitzpatrick ss1824865799 adyh
Image Credit: April Visuals/Shutterstock

Team/s: St. Louis Rams, Buffalo Bills, Tennessee Titans, Houston Texans, New York Jets, Tampa Bay Buccaneers, Miami Dolphins, Washington Commanders
Passing yards: 34,990
Years active: 2005-2021

Nicknamed “Fitzmagic,” Fitzpatrick was beloved for his journeyman status and ability to provide unexpected spark to multiple teams. His Harvard education and beard became as famous as his unpredictable but exciting playing style.

28. Ryan Tannehill

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » ryan tannehill wc
Image Credit: Chipermc, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Team/s: Miami Dolphins, Tennessee Titans
Passing yards: 34,881
Years active: 2012-2023

Tannehill transformed from a struggling quarterback in Miami to a key player for the Tennessee Titans. He found renewed success under coach Mike Vrabel, becoming a crucial part of the Titans’ offensive strategy.

29. Patrick Mahomes

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » patrick mahomes ss1311591119 adyh
Image Credit: Jamie Lamor Thompson/Shutterstock

Team/s: Kansas City Chiefs
Passing yards: 35,699
Years active: 2017-present

Mahomes has already revolutionized quarterback play with his extraordinary arm talent and improvisational skills. He led the Kansas City Chiefs to multiple Super Bowl victories, becoming the face of a new generation of NFL quarterbacks.

30. Steve Young

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » steve young wc
Image Credit: Presidio of Monterey, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Team/s: Tampa Bay Buccaneers, San Francisco 49ers
Passing yards: 33,124
Years active: 1984-1999

Young emerged from Joe Montana’s shadow to become one of the most dynamic quarterbacks in NFL history, ultimately winning Super Bowl MVP and three consecutive passing titles. He was a trailblazing left-handed quarterback who revolutionized the position with his exceptional mobility and precision passing .

31. Terry Bradshaw

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » terry bradshaw wc
Image Credit: The ASI Show, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Team/s: Pittsburgh Steelers
Passing yards: 27,989
Years active: 1970-1983

Bradshaw was the cornerstone of the Pittsburgh Steelers’ legendary dynasty, leading the team to four Super Bowl victories during the 1970s. Beyond his on-field success, he became a beloved media personality and broadcaster after his playing career, showcasing his charismatic personality.

32. Roger Staubach

Touchdown Titans: The 32 Quarterbacks Who Defined NFL History » staubach cowboy wc
Image Credit: here, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Team/s: Dallas Cowboys
Passing yards: 22,700
Years active: 1969-1979

Known as “Captain America” for his Naval Academy background, Staubach was a pioneering dual-threat quarterback who transformed the Dallas Cowboys’ offense. He led the Cowboys to two Super Bowl victories and was named Super Bowl MVP, becoming one of the most iconic quarterbacks of his era despite playing in an earlier, less pass-friendly NFL.

Martha A. Lavallie
Martha A. Lavallie
Author & Editor | + posts

Martha is a journalist with close to a decade of experience in uncovering and reporting on the most compelling stories of our time. Passionate about staying ahead of the curve, she specializes in shedding light on trending topics and captivating global narratives. Her insightful articles have garnered acclaim, making her a trusted voice in today's dynamic media landscape.