Where Fans Don’t Care: The 5 Most Dispassionate Sports Towns in America

Have you ever wondered which cities in the United States don’t seem to be as into sports as others? Well, there are actually a few places where sports passion isn’t as high. 

Here are 15 cities where sports might not have as big of a fan base compared to other larger cities. 

1. Jacksonville, Florida

jacksonville beach ss2283775941
Image Credit: David Garrison/Shutterstock

The Jacksonville Jaguars have faced consistently low attendance numbers and struggled with fan support despite the team’s efforts to improve. (ref) Also, the Jaguars have had limited success in the NFL, with few playoff appearances and a generally poor win-loss record.

Jacksonville is a smaller market with fewer sports teams and has been tagged for being a “bad fan base,”(ref) which can lead to less overall sports enthusiasm compared to larger cities.

2. Cincinnati, Ohio

cincinnati dp11165866
Image Credit: rudi1976/Deposit Photos

The Cincinnati Bengals have experienced long stretches of poor performance and limited playoff success, (ref) which can dampen fan enthusiasm.

Cincinnati, while passionate about its sports teams, has a smaller fan base (ref) which can impact the level of fan engagement and financial support. The city’s sports teams also often face competitive disadvantages compared to teams in larger markets, affecting overall sports culture.

3. Buffalo, New York

buffalo new york dp13148912
Image Credit: chloe7992/Deposit Photos

Buffalo’s harsh winters can impact fan attendance and enthusiasm, as cold weather games can be less appealing.

In addition, the city has faced economic challenges which can affect the local sports culture and financial support for teams. Although the Buffalo Bills have had success in recent years, the city has historically faced long periods without major sports victories since 1965. (ref)

4. Charlotte, North Carolina

Charlotte North Carolina dp288189770
Image Credit: Kevin@collegevibe.com/Deposit Photos

Charlotte is a relatively new sports market with teams like the Carolina Panthers and Charlotte Hornets having less historical success compared to older franchises.

However, the city is still developing a deep-rooted sports culture, which can affect the level of passion and support. Charlotte also competes with other Southern cities for sports attention and has yet to build a historically passionate fan base.

5. San Diego, California

SanDiego dp103206606
Image Credit: sepavone/Deposit Photos

The Chargers’ relocation to Los Angeles in 2017 left a gap in San Diego’s sports landscape and impacted the city’s sports culture.

San Diego has yet to secure a major league sports team to fill the void left by the Chargers, affecting local sports enthusiasm. Even before the Chargers’ departure, San Diego’s sports teams faced challenges in maintaining consistent fan support since its last title in 1963. (ref)

6. Atlanta, Georgia

atlanta georgia dp288188626
Image Credit: Kevin@collegevibe.com/Deposit Photos

Atlanta has experienced several relocations and changes in its sports teams. The Braves moved to Atlanta from Milwaukee in 1966, the Flames (NHL) left for Calgary in 1980, and the Thrashers (NHL) moved to Winnipeg in 2011. These moves disrupted fan loyalty and sports culture.

While the Atlanta Braves have had periods of success, the Falcons have struggled with inconsistency, and the Hawks have had limited playoff success in recent years. Furthermore, Atlanta’s sports fans have sometimes been criticized for lacking enthusiasm and its great divide. (ref)

7. Detroit, Michigan

detroit michigan road dp429874252
Image Credit: sernovik/Deposit Photos

Detroit has faced economic difficulties, (ref) which have impacted its sports teams and facilities. The economic downturn affected local support and investment in sports.

The Lions have historically struggled with poor performance, and the Pistons have seen fluctuating success. The Tigers and Red Wings have had more success but have faced their own challenges.

Teams like the Pistons and Tigers have gone through long rebuilding phases that can dampen fan enthusiasm. (ref)

8. Cleveland, Ohio

cleveland ohio dp173353056
Image Credit: sepavone/Deposit Photos

Despite recent successes by the Cleveland Cavaliers in the NBA, the city experienced a long period without major championships, which affected overall sports morale.

Besides, the Cleveland Browns have had a history of poor performance and organizational struggles. (ref) The Indians (now Guardians) had periods of underachievement before recent improvements. (ref)

Like Detroit, Cleveland has faced economic issues that have impacted local sports support. (ref)

9. Minnesota (Minneapolis-Saint Paul)

Minneapolis Minnesota dp13261480
Image Credit: rudi1976/Deposit Photos

The harsh winters can affect fan attendance and enthusiasm, particularly for outdoor sports. The Minnesota Vikings have had periods of underperformance, and the Minnesota Timberwolves have struggled with consistency. 

While the Minnesota Wild and Twins have had some success, the overall sports culture can be uneven. (ref) The region has had fewer major championships compared to other sports cities.

10. Sacramento, California

sacramento california dp662415730
Image Credit: paulbradyphoto/Deposit Photos

The Sacramento Kings (NBA) have struggled with performance issues (ref) and have not experienced major playoff success in recent years.

Also, Sacramento has fewer major sports teams compared to larger cities, which can affect overall sports culture and fan engagement. As a smaller market city, Sacramento faces challenges related to financial support and media coverage.

These are the top cities in the U.S. where sports fans might not be as enthusiastic due to different factors. Of course, this doesn’t mean people in these cities don’t enjoy sports at all.

Martha A. Lavallie
Martha A. Lavallie
Author & Editor | + posts

Martha is a journalist with close to a decade of experience in uncovering and reporting on the most compelling stories of our time. Passionate about staying ahead of the curve, she specializes in shedding light on trending topics and captivating global narratives. Her insightful articles have garnered acclaim, making her a trusted voice in today's dynamic media landscape.